OPENvsCLOSEDGet updates

The fight over who controls AI

Who should hold the keys to artificial intelligence?

A few companies want the most powerful AI kept behind their own doors. A growing coalition wants it open, so anyone can download it, inspect it and run it. We track the fight, lay out both sides fairly, and come down on open. When closed wins a round, we say so.

The Scoreboard

● Updated Nov 21, 2026 · How we score

Dead even. Closed leads on raw power, on money, and on the ability to recall a model. Open leads on price, control and what developers actually use. Washington hasn't picked a side.

  1. Capability

    OpenTrails by about 4 months on the broadest index, and 8 to 10 months on tests it can't study in advance

    ClosedHolds the frontier

    Closed

    Four measurers, four numbers, one direction. The private-test figure matters most, because public tests can leak into training data. The best open model today, Kimi K3.1 Pro, ranks 12th overall on BenchLM.

    Sources: Epoch AI, May 29, 2026 · NeoTeo, Sep 17, 2026 · Håvard Tveit Ihle, LessWrong, May 2026 · Second Source, Oct 17, 2026 · BenchLM, Nov 7, 2026

  2. Price

    OpenThe cheapest open model runs about 90% cheaper than a closed flagship. A closed token costs roughly 7 times an open one on OpenRouter

    ClosedPremium per-use pricing set by the maker

    Open

    The middle of the open pack is closer: the median open frontier model was about 15% cheaper than GPT-5.2 in July.

    Sources: Tomasz Tunguz, Jul 20, 2026 · FourWeekMBA, Nov 2026

  3. Control

    OpenDownload it, inspect it, change it, and run it on your own hardware

    ClosedRent it through one company's servers, on that company's terms

    Open

    Your data never has to leave your building. Licences still vary: see how open each model really is.

  4. Usage

    OpenAbout 72% of tokens on OpenRouter in September, and above 62% every week since July

    ClosedAbout 28%

    Open

    OpenRouter shows what developers pick when switching is easy. It isn't the whole AI economy, and most of the open share is Chinese models.

    Sources: OpenRouter, Sep 22, 2026 · Dror Poleg, week to Nov 8, 2026

  5. Spend

    OpenAbout 27% of dollars on OpenRouter, up from 11% in January

    ClosedAbout 73%

    Closed

    Open models are cheap, so they win on volume and lose on revenue. This is the category most likely to flip next.

    Sources: OpenRouter, Sep 22, 2026

  6. Recall

    OpenOnce released, copies can't be pulled back

    ClosedCan be patched, throttled or withdrawn by the maker

    Closed

    This is the closed camp's strongest point, and we score it for them.

    Sources: Dario Amodei, Anthropic, Jul 27, 2026

  7. Washington

    OpenA bill backing American open models is one vote from the House floor. The White House framework leaves open models alone

    ClosedFour moves in one week of November aimed at Chinese open models, which are most of the top open models

    No point

    Washington is for American open models and against Chinese ones. Until it picks, nobody gets this point.

    Sources: House Energy and Commerce Committee, Sep 16, 2026 · Reuters via The Globe and Mail, Nov 18, 2026 · BankInfoSecurity, Nov 20, 2026

Play-by-play

The latest moves, scored

Each play gets tagged for the side it helped. Washington made four moves touching Chinese open models in the week of November 16 alone.

  1. Split

    House report: ban Chinese models in government, fund American open ones

    Two House committees publish a joint report after a seven-month investigation. It asks the White House to bar federal agencies from using Chinese models, and to launch a national American open-weight initiative with public computing power, shared testing and government purchasing behind it.

    via BankInfoSecurity, Reuters via The Jerusalem Post
  2. Point · Closed

    Cursor says it may drop Chinese open models

    Cursor, the AI coding tool, tells House investigators it will explore phasing out Chinese-developed open-weight models because of geopolitical risk. It has set no decision and no timetable. Cursor built its Composer 2 model on Moonshot's Kimi K2.5.

    via CNBC, Unite.AI, BankInfoSecurity
  3. Point · Open

    Thinking Machines releases Inkling 2 Mini with open weights

    Mira Murati's Thinking Machines Lab releases Inkling 2 Mini, a 26.4-billion-parameter model, with open weights. It adds to a short list of American labs shipping open models.

    via AI Weekly
  4. Point · Closed

    White House weighs making companies disclose Chinese AI use

    Reuters reports the administration is considering a rule that would make U.S. companies publicly disclose their use of Chinese AI models. Three people familiar with the talks describe it as a way to discourage use without a ban that could anger industry or Beijing.

    via Reuters via The Globe and Mail
  5. Point · Closed

    Federal commission urges limits on Chinese open models in sensitive uses

    The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission sends Congress its annual report. Recommendation 18 would give Commerce 180 days to identify sensitive uses and block new deployments of Chinese open-weight models there unless their safeguards pass independent testing. Recommendation 19 would require disclosure when governments and businesses use them.

    via U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, CASRAI, FourWeekMBA
  6. Split

    Commerce closes the overseas data center loophole

    The Commerce Department issues a rule requiring licenses for chip exports to overseas data centers that supply large amounts of computing power to companies based in China. It took effect November 19. The rule targets chips, not open models, but the labs it squeezes ship most of the world's top open weights.

    via NBC News, Orrick
All 32 plays

Where it gets decided

Law tracker

3help open3restrict open6to watch

  • Federal · HouseHelps open

    Open-Source AI Leadership Act (H.R. 10152)

    Directs the Commerce Department to support adoption of American open AI models, find what holds them back, and publish yearly assessments of open models from adversary nations. It states that nothing in it lets Commerce ban an open model. Sponsored by Rep. Gabe Evans (R-CO).

    Reported to the full House, 26 to 21 · Awaiting a floor vote

  • Federal · White House and TreasuryRestricts open

    Chinese AI disclosure rule

    Would make U.S. companies say publicly, on their own websites, when they use Chinese AI models. Described by people familiar with it as a way to discourage use without a ban.

    Under consideration · First reported Nov 18, 2026

  • Federal · Advisory commissionRestricts open

    USCC recommendations 18 and 19

    The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission asks Congress to have Commerce identify sensitive uses within 180 days and block new deployments of Chinese open-weight models there unless independently tested safeguards are in place. It also asks for inventories and for disclosure of Chinese model use.

    Recommended to Congress, Nov 18, 2026 · No bill yet

  • Federal · House committeesWatch

    House report on Chinese open models

    The Homeland Security and Select China committees recommend barring federal agencies from Chinese models, consistent government testing of models, and sanctions for companies that illicitly copy American models. They also call for a national American open-weight initiative with public computing power and federal purchasing.

    Published Nov 20, 2026 · Recommendations only

All 12 bills, rules and proposals

Get the score when it changes

One short email when the scoreboard moves or a law changes. Nothing else.

Want to weigh in? Build a letter to your representative.